A place for everything

An LVD Strippit laser system keeps Wrayco Industries Inc. organized and profitable

February 2008 - It's easy to talk about efficiency. Buzzwords get thrown around, and many times nothing of consequence actually happens. That's not the case at Wrayco Industries Inc., Stow, Ohio. The family-owned precision fabricating shop streamlined its operations with two LVD Strippit Axel 3015 L flying optics lasers, complete with multiple CNC-controlled automatic pallet stations linked to a double storage tower.

Mike Gibb, vice president of manufacturing, says, "Wrayco Industries was started in 1980 by my grandparents Willard and Bobbie Wray and my father Gary Gibb. The original plan was to own and operate a small family business and live happily ever after."

However, plans changed. The company has "grown to employ 275 people and operates seven days a week," notes Gibb. As a result, it needed a cutting system that could accommodate the business.

Enter LVD Strippit. Wrayco had a previous relationship with the company, having used its press brakes exclusively, says Gibb. In addition, "We were happy with the design of their automated material handling system, which, we felt, was much more robust. We were impressed with its ability to lift heavy sheet, load heavy sheet and withstand the wear and tear of running the machine day in and day out."

A modular system
Wrayco specializes in the fabrication of fuel and hydraulic tanks for the construction industry. "Our major customers are Caterpillar, Case New Holland and Volvo," says Gibb. Adding the laser to its capabilities has allowed the company to improve its quality. "By having such a repeatable machine, we have been able to improve our quality of fit-up, which leads to a better tank," he says. "Without the laser system, we wouldn't have been able to grow like we have."

The flying optics design on the laser allows the cutting head to move freely on three axes. It can achieve axis positioning of speeds up to 170 meters per minute, regardless of sheet size or weight. Sixty percent to 70 percent of the workpieces Wrayco processes are large, up to 60 inches by 120 inches, with significant travel distances from one cut to the next.

"We use our lasers to cut from 1-millimeter-thick material up to 12-millimeter-thick material," Gibb says. "We could go heavier, but we have a heavier burn table for anything over that thickness. We cut mostly mild steel for the construction industry, but we also cut stainless and aluminum on a regular basis."

Gibb says that Wrayco used to "shear and punch all the parts we made." As a result, he notes, "The parts were not nearly as accurate and required a lot of special tooling to produce. The laser eliminates the need for special tooling and is much more accurate on profiles than the plasma torches or the punch presses were. Also, our lasers are fully automated, which allows us to run 24 hours a day, seven days a week. We can also run the machines unmanned for hours at a time. We are focusing on lean principles, and the lasers give a consistent cycle time that works well for capacity planning. While being consistent, the tower system that we've married to our system allows us to change sizes and gauges of material at will. We've been able to drop our lot sizes from seven-day lot sizes to one-day lot sizes."

The multi-pallet, CNC-controlled load and unload system enables loading and unloading functions to be performed independently, within 40 seconds. This frees the laser operators to perform other tasks, including programming the next group of parts, removing a table of finished parts or receiving incoming material. The loading mechanism handles plates up to 3/4 inch and stack heights up to 61/2 inches per station.

Stefan Colle, laser products manager for LVD Strippit, says that the Axel system is unique, "particularly the load and unload system. The way we've designed the loading and unloading is with a fork system that rides in and out of the cutting area. The parts are taken out of the cutting area and stacked on a pallet." Colle notes that one of the most desirable characteristics of the system is that it's modular.

"You can start out with a single pallet and end up with a double-tower system," he says. But it's not necessary to buy that from the start. "As more automation is added to the laser system, the more flexibility there is to schedule longer-run jobs in unattended mode."

The system has served Wrayco well. "Like everyone else, we're trying to focus on lean techniques," says Gibb. "We've implemented a kanban system for scheduling so we're using a pull system. With the tower system being tied into our lasers, at any moment I can pull off a program and the very next sheet in that machine could be a different gauge, a different size or a different thickness, and we could go on without skipping a beat. We have changeover times of three to four minutes. With the tower system, we run small batches of the same material at one time. We're changing material times and thicknesses by the hour, sometimes multiple times per hour."

Colle also notes that the tower system keeps Wrayco organized. "They go through a lot of turnover of material. The purchase of the warehouse system provided Wrayco with better control of its inventory," he says. "If you stack material somewhere in your building, it's a bit hard to control. With the tower system, every minute of the day you can request a status of your inventory."

Since implementing the tower system and the second laser, Wrayco has gone from $26 million in business to $44 million. And "I still only have those two machines as my primary first operations," says Gibb. "I haven't had to outsource anything. By using the tower system and the dependability of the machines, we've been able to go from $26 million in sales to $44 million by quickly changing over material, lowering our work in progress and having faith in the machine that it's going to stay up and running."

Open 24 hours
The LVD Strippit system allows Wrayco to work around the clock, also increasing productivity. Colle notes that Wrayco "wanted to have a system that would work 24 hours a day and wouldn't give them too many headaches or downtime."

Colle says that one of the most important things about running a laser unattended is that the right material is in the machine. "The technology built into the Wrayco system checks that all the sheets for a job are available, checks for proper sheet thickness, length and size before laser cutting. In the event that material is missing, an alarm is generated, and the job will not be released."

For Wrayco, running unmanned wasn't a big change, as its shop already runs around the clock. "We've found that the lasers are repeatable machines," says Gibb. "The programs are written in advance, and then they're stored in the memory on the system. Typically, when we run in an unmanned fashion on the weekends, we program in advance and do longer-running programs. We've done it for up to 12 hours at a time before we come in and drop out tables. We try to do our higher-volume work on the weekends so we can focus on short, quick runs during the production week."

Easy to learn
Like any machine, Gibb notes that there is a learning curve, but it's not very steep--essentially involving learning some basic functions and parameters. In addition, "there's been very little maintenance that we've had to do on any type of cutting technology,"?he says. "LVD's been very supportive on getting that up and running and training us on the upkeep of the machine.

"We've developed a training program where an operator can go from never operating the machine to being a fully approved operator in under two weeks," Gibb notes, saying that given the size and complexity of the system, he feels that this is very good.

And Gibb says that if you follow the maintenance schedules, upkeep isn't a problem. "Everyone struggles with making sure the preventative maintenance is performed at the right time,"?he says. "The nice thing about an automated machine is you get used to it running all the time, but we focus on doing a good job in capacity planning so that we can plan for that machine to be down for an hour or two. But we have to stay on top of the maintenance. If we don't, our mirrors get dirty and our cut quality starts to go." Gibb says that although the machines appear to be robust, "they have to be taken care of, otherwise you run into issues quickly. It doesn't pay to push the machine past its regularly scheduled maintenance."

While a laser system isn't the right choice for every operation, more companies are discovering the benefits of automation. People that buy these systems are from all different areas, says Colle, from job shops to large OEMs. "More customers are buying automation because they can be more efficient and more productive," he notes. "When you run a laser 24 hours a day versus eight hours a day, it will help you be a whole lot more competitive."

"Automation doesn't really need to be expensive anymore," Colle says. "We now add automation to our entry-level machines. Today, you can start cutting unattended for less than half a million dollars. MM

By Lauren Duensing, from the February 2008 issue of Modern Metals.